Of Liberty and Necessity

James A. Harris · ISBN 9780199234752
Of Liberty and Necessity | Zookal Textbooks | Zookal Textbooks
Print on Demand
Leaves '12-15' days after printing
Subscribe & Save
$112.95  Save $27.17
$112.95  Save $5.72
Zookal account needed
Read online instantly with Zookal eReader
Access online & offline
Note: Subscribe and save discount does not apply to eTextbooks.
Publisher Oxford University Press UK
Author(s) James A. Harris
Subtitle The Free Will Debate in Eighteenth-Century British Philosophy
Published 1st November 2007
Related course codes

The Free Will Debate in Eighteenth-Century British Philosophy

In Of Liberty and Necessity James A. Harris presents the first comprehensive account of the free will problem in eighteenth-century British philosophy. Harris proposes new interpretations of the positions of familiar figures such as Locke, Hume, Edwards, and Reid. He also gives careful attention to writers such as William King, Samuel Clarke, Anthony Collins, Lord Kames, James Beattie, David Hartley, Joseph Priestley, and Dugald Stewart, who, while
well-known in the eighteenth century, have since been largely ignored by historians of philosophy. Through detailed textual analysis, and by making precise use of a variety of different contexts, Harris elucidates the
contribution that each of these writers makes to the eighteenth-century discussion of the will and its freedom. In this period, the question of the nature of human freedom is posed principally in terms of the influence of motives upon the will. On one side of the debate are those who believe that we are free in our choices. A motive, these philosophers believe, constitutes a reason to act in a particular way, but it is up to us which motive we act upon. On the other side
of the debate are those who believe that, on the contrary, there is no such thing as freedom of choice. According to these philosophers, one motive is always intrinsically stronger than the rest and so
is the one that must determine choice. Several important issues are raised as this disagreement is explored and developed, including the nature of motives, the value of 'indifference' to the will's freedom, the distinction between 'moral' and 'physical' necessity, the relation between the will and the understanding, and the internal coherence of the concept of freedom of will. One of Harris's primary objectives is to place this debate in the context of the
eighteenth-century concern with replicating in the mental sphere what Newton had achieved in the philosophy of nature. All of the philosophers discussed in Of Liberty and Necessity conceive of themselves as
'experimental' reasoners, and, when examining the will, focus primarily upon what experience reveals about the influence of motives upon choice. The nature and significance of introspection is therefore at the very centre of the free will problem in this period, as is the question of what can legitimately be inferred from observable regularities in human behaviour.


Save 20% off Textbooks + free shipping with Zookal Study Premium every time you shop and more...

  • Free courtesy eTextbook on a wide range of selected titles
  • Get step-by-step solutions from expert tutors
  • Access powerful online study tools to help you study on the go


Instant rewards

Zookal Study gives you the best price on textbooks instantly with full access to experience 24/7 study help you can rely on from day 1 until exam time.


Cancel anytime

No commitment, no worries. Try Zookal Study for 1 month and cancel at anytime. Cancelling is made easy via your Zookal Study account.

Unlock study tools fit for every moment

Homework Help

Solutions Library

Test Prep



Translation missing: